P2P lending strategy under funding pressure
Peer-to-peer lending is complex because every lender needs a source of cash. A bank has an internal treasury, and an NBFI relies on credit lines or warehouse lines. Banks can obtain cash relatively cheaply, then securitize their lending. A P2P lender has to persuade small investors to provide the money, and those investors usually require a higher rate.
That makes the interest expense and cost of funds for a P2P lender much higher than for a bank or an NBFI. There is a saying in banking and finance that you buy risk and sell trust. P2P lending amplifies that idea because the platform must win the trust of small investors as it lends their money.
How does your peer-to-peer platform raise money versus a bank or NBFI?
A standard NBFI lender may manage two to three warehouse lines. It manages each relationship, and once a line is locked in, it can use that funding for the next three to four years.
A bank manages its treasury internally. Its lending department speaks to the treasury team when it needs capital. In peer-to-peer (P2P) lending, your platform has to win capital every day, just as it wins borrowers every day. You have to do both together.
Why is origination harder for your P2P lending platform?
Origination is the most important thing for your P2P lending platform. It has two parts. You need to originate good enough borrowers for investors to put money into, and you need to originate enough investors to put the money in. These two sides can fall out of step.
Sometimes you have plenty of investor money but no good borrowers to deploy the capital to. During a general market crisis, or a crisis at one P2P lender, the small investor market and the wider pool can become more conservative. Issues at one P2P lender happen quite often, and the result can be a lack of capital. That affects borrower acquisition because retail marketing is difficult to turn up or down quickly, so acquisition cost can skyrocket as retail marketing activity continues.
What rules shape how your P2P platform can lend and earn?
Regulators have targeted pooled money rather than the number of investors funding each loan. China’s 2016 rules for online lending barred platforms from running capital pools and guaranteeing investors’ returns. Many investors funding one borrower is the ordinary shape of P2P lending. In the EU, Regulation (EU) 2020/1503 covers platforms that facilitate loans to businesses, including assessing the credit risk of projects or project owners. Crowdfunding of loans to consumers is outside its scope and remains subject to consumer credit law and national rules.
Investor cash is held under custody rules. From 2017, China required P2P platforms to keep investor funds with one commercial bank as custodian. Indonesia requires P2P platforms to move lenders’ money through escrow and virtual accounts. Under the EU crowdfunding regulation, payments go through an authorised payment service provider.
A P2P platform earns mainly from fees for arranging and servicing loans. Some regulators limit those fees. Indonesia caps the total interest and fees a P2P borrower can be charged. The EU crowdfunding regulation requires the fees to be disclosed to investors.
Who carries the loss when your borrowers stop paying?
Whether your platform may cushion investors against defaults depends on the market. China’s 2016 rules banned P2P platforms from guaranteeing returns or covering losses themselves. The UK allowed provision funds under disclosure rules. Where no such cushion exists, investors carry the loss.
When borrowers stop repaying, investors feel it directly. They can see that repayments are stuck, and they wait for their cash. That affects everything. A secondary market can provide liquidity, because distressed loans can be sold and repackaged. It can create another source of revenue, but it can also create another source of trouble.
A secondary market lets anyone see the performance of your portfolio. When investors start dumping loans, the market shows that something is bad and how bad it is. That can trigger the rest of the investors to pull their money from the platform. It is a run on the bank. Then there is less money for new origination and no future growth, while acquisition costs rise because of marketing and unit cost profitability suffers.
What happened to P2P lending in China?
The industry needs regulation because there was a great deal of fraud in the early years of peer-to-peer lending. In China, the huge Ezubao fraud showed the scale of the problem. Ezubao was an online lending platform launched in 2014 by Anhui Yucheng Holdings Group. From June 2014 to December 2015, it raised more than 50 billion yuan, about €7 billion, from about 900,000 investors across the country with fabricated projects and promised returns.
A former executive told the authorities that 95 percent of the borrowers listed on the platform were fictional entities created by the company. Its founder, Ding Ning, said on state television, “We fabricated projects to raise money.” When the police made arrests in early 2016, the company had failed to repay 38 billion yuan, about €5 billion. In September 2017, a Beijing court sentenced Ding Ning to life in prison for illegal fundraising.
Peer-to-peer lending is one of the most fragile and complicated lending business models. That risk may be why China closed it as an allowed industry. P2P lenders were told to wind down their positions and run off their portfolios, while the bigger players were told to convert to classic consumer lending businesses with leverage managed under banking regulations. China had about 5,000 operating P2P lending platforms at the peak, but after a crackdown began in 2016, the number fell to 29 by the end of June 2020 and to three by November 2020, according to the banking regulator. In 2020, the regulator’s chairman, Guo Shuqing, said the platforms still owed investors more than 800 billion yuan, about €100 billion, and by early 2021 the industry had essentially been shut down.
What does your regulator expect from your P2P credit decisions?
Your credit decisions need auditability, traceability and explainability because they direct money that often comes from retail investors. Retail investors are protected in many jurisdictions, so regulators focus closely on the decisions that affect those funds.
Your decision logic has to cover how funds are disbursed, KYC, affordability, eligibility criteria, credit risk and risk management. It also has to cover collections. If someone says in the market that your P2P lender does not manage risk well, retail investors can pull back, withdraw their capital or stop putting in new capital, which can affect the business.
How do you make your platform’s risk grades hold up?
When your platform tells the market that a grade represents a particular level of risk, you have to prove that claim over time and show it. That makes scoring model stability one of the most important parts of credit scoring. Newcomers to lending often want cool scores and cool technology, and those scores may not be stable.
Small investors have expectations when they are told that A is the best grade, B is okay, C is so-so and D is terrible, with risk-based pricing. What they hate is when those expectations are not met, such as B performing worse than D. Every score needs proper rank order, so the modeller must check stability before relying on statistics.
When investors become frightened and pull their money, the operations of the whole business model start to suffer. That damages profitability as well.
Where does your P2P lending platform usually go wrong?
New platforms and incoming lenders often think that being cool, using lots of technology and getting underwriting right matter most. The most important thing is the whole risk process. That includes good anti-fraud detection, smooth collections, enough collection staff and operations sized so the model scales efficiently.
Collections also need to run smoothly because they affect everything. The platform needs to manage PR as well as marketing, so small investors feel that their money is somewhere safe.
Which P2P lending models last for your platform?
The cost of capital is much more expensive, and there are more risks, so you usually need to lend at higher rates. To make the business sustainable, many P2P lenders go into payday loans because they do not care about that segment and only need its high interest rates.
The other road is lending that standard banks will not touch. That can mean medium-sized lending such as SMB loans, or complex cases such as expensive machinery and smaller real estate. These cases are too complex and too small for a bank to spend the underwriting time, and they do not fit the consumer loan category or a classic business banking loan.
The platforms that win automate, choose a complex niche, acquire customers well, put the money in and manage the whole risk process. It stays hard because of the volatility, and sustainability is very difficult. A P2P lending model that lasts must be the best at customer acquisition because once a niche works, a banker with cheaper money can copy it and take even more risk at first, since the margins are bigger.